Decision guide
Steam Tracing vs Electric Tracing for Tubing Bundles
Published:
A heat traced tubing bundle keeps an instrument or analyser line warm with one of two heat sources. Electric tracing uses a resistance heating cable that runs beside the process tube. Steam tracing uses a small tracer tube that carries plant steam. Both are built into the bundle in the factory, under the same insulation and outer jacket. Which one fits depends on the utilities at the line, the temperature you must hold, how long the run is and the area classification. This guide compares the two so you can choose for your own plant.
Request a quoteElectric and steam tracing compared
| Electric tracing (EHTL) | Steam tracing (SHTL) | |
|---|---|---|
| Heat source | A resistance heating cable beside the process tube | A copper or stainless-steel tracer tube carrying plant steam |
| Utility needed at the line | An electrical supply with circuit protection | Plant steam, with steam traps and a route for the condensate |
| Temperature control | Set by the cable type and, where needed, a thermostat or controller. Self-regulating cable lowers its output as it warms | Set by the steam pressure. Heavy (direct-contact) or light (separated) construction changes how much heat reaches the tube |
| Temperatures in Techwin bundles | Constant-wattage cable maintains up to 200 °C (392 °F), with exposure to 260 °C (500 °F). Self-regulating cables cover lower ranges up to about 150 °C (302 °F) | Saturated steam up to 17 bar (246 psi), about 204 °C (399 °F) |
| Run length | Up to 450 m (1,475 ft) per circuit with power-limiting cable; about 150 m (490 ft) with constant-wattage cable | Set by the steam pressure and by where condensate can be removed along the line |
| Hazardous areas | The heating cable must be certified for the zone, gas group and temperature class | No electrical parts. The hottest surface must stay below the ignition temperature of the gas present |
| Routine attention | Electrical checks on the circuit and its controls | Steam traps, leaks and condensate removal |
| Best fit | Controlled temperatures, long runs, and lines with no steam nearby | Plants with steam already at the line, and services that need a lot of heat |
When electric tracing is the better choice
- There is no steam near the line, or bringing it there would mean new steam and condensate piping.
- The temperature must stay inside a set band, or the fluid would be damaged by steam temperature.
- The run is long. Power-limiting cable in Techwin bundles allows circuits up to 450 m (1,475 ft).
- The duty is freeze protection or a moderate maintain temperature, where self-regulating cable adjusts its own output.
- You want to monitor or switch the tracing from a control system.
When steam tracing can make more sense
- Plant steam is already available at the line and condensate can be drained or returned.
- The line needs a lot of heat, or must warm up quickly from cold. Heavy steam tracing puts the tracer in direct contact with the process tube.
- There is no reliable electrical supply in the field, or the site prefers not to add electrical equipment in that area.
- The plant already maintains steam systems and traps and wants the tracing to match.
Questions that decide the choice
Answer these for your own line. If most answers fall in one column, that method is usually the simpler one to install and run.
| Question | Points to electric | Points to steam |
|---|---|---|
| Is steam available near the line? | No, or only at a distance | Yes, with a place to remove condensate |
| Is a reliable power supply available? | Yes | No, or limited |
| How closely must the temperature be held? | Within a band, or the fluid is sensitive to overheating | It only has to stay hot, and the fluid tolerates steam temperature. Light tracing suits gentler duties |
| How long is the run? | Long continuous runs | Runs that suit the available steam pressure and trap positions |
| What is the area classification? | A heating cable certified for the zone and temperature class is available | Electrical equipment is to be avoided, and the steam temperature is acceptable for the gas present |
| What does the plant already maintain? | Electrical tracing and its controls | Steam distribution and steam traps |
Neither method is better in general. Many plants use both: steam where it is already at hand, electric where it is not. We do not quote a standard running-cost difference, because it depends on your steam and power costs. If neither is needed and the line only has to lose less heat, pre-insulated tubing without a tracer may be enough.
What to send so we can recommend one
- Fluid or gas, and the temperature the line must be held at (or freeze protection only)
- Highest temperature the line will see, for example during steam-out
- Utilities at the line: voltage available, or steam pressure
- Tube material, size and number of tubes in the bundle
- Length of each run
- Area classification: zone or division, gas group and temperature class
- Minimum ambient temperature and site environment
Choosing steam? See light vs heavy steam tracing. Working in a classified area? See hazardous-area heat traced tubing.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between steam tracing and electric tracing?
Electric tracing heats the line with a resistance heating cable and needs an electrical supply. Steam tracing heats it with a small tracer tube that carries plant steam and needs steam traps and condensate removal. In a tubing bundle, either heat source is built in beside the process tube under the same insulation and jacket.
Which is better, steam or electric heat tracing?
It depends on the site. Electric tracing suits controlled temperatures, long runs and lines with no steam nearby. Steam tracing suits plants where steam is already at the line and the service needs a lot of heat. Many plants use both.
What temperatures can electric and steam traced tubing maintain?
In Techwin electric bundles, constant-wattage cable maintains up to 200 °C (392 °F) with exposure to 260 °C (500 °F), and self-regulating cables cover lower ranges up to about 150 °C (302 °F). Techwin steam traced bundles take saturated steam up to 17 bar (246 psi), about 204 °C (399 °F). In both, the outer jacket stays below 60 °C (140 °F) for personnel protection.
Can steam traced tubing be used in a hazardous area?
A steam traced bundle has no electrical parts, so it needs no electrical certification. What matters is surface temperature: the hottest surface must stay below the ignition temperature of the gas present. For electric tracing, the heating cable must be certified for the zone, gas group and temperature class.
Not sure which tracing suits your line?
Send the fluid, the temperature to hold, the utilities at the line and the run lengths. Our engineers will recommend electric or steam tracing and price the bundle.
Request a quote