Engineering guide
Freeze Protection of Instrument Sensing Lines at Power Plants
Published:
A generating unit can trip because one small tube froze. Sensing lines carry pressure from the process to a transmitter, and many of them hold still water. When that water freezes, the transmitter reads wrong and the control system acts on a false signal. After the February 2021 winter storm, US regulators found that frozen transmitters and sensing lines were among the most common causes of generating-unit outages. This guide sets out what the cold-weather rules ask of plant owners, which lines are usually at risk, and how a factory-made tubing bundle protects them.
Request a quoteWhat the February 2021 investigation found
The joint staff report by FERC, NERC and the regional entities (November 2021) broke down the freezing problems at generating units by region.
| Region | Share of generating-unit freezing issues caused by frozen instrumentation |
|---|---|
| ERCOT (Texas) | 34.5% |
| MISO South | 55% |
| SPP | 14.7% |
The staff presentation of the report describes frozen instrumentation as transmitters and sensing lines. It adds that protecting transmitters, sensing lines and instrumentation, together with wind turbine blades, could have cut the generation lost to freezing by 67 percent in ERCOT, 47 percent in SPP and 55 percent in MISO South.
What the cold-weather rules require
None of these rules names a product. They make the owner responsible for identifying the components that matter and for protecting them. Read the current text of each rule for your own unit; this table is a summary, not legal advice.
| Rule | Who it covers | What it asks for |
|---|---|---|
| NERC EOP-012-3, Extreme Cold Weather Preparedness and Operations | Generator Owners and Operators of bulk-power generating units in North America | Identify the Generator Cold Weather Critical Components and document the freeze protection on them, including measures against wind. Inspect and maintain that freeze protection every year. Units that enter commercial operation on or after 1 October 2027 must be able to run at their Extreme Cold Weather Temperature with a sustained 20 mph (32 km/h) wind for at least 12 continuous hours. Earlier units must have freeze protection for that temperature or a corrective action plan to add it. |
| 16 Texas Administrative Code §25.55, Weather Emergency Preparedness (Public Utility Commission of Texas) | Generation entities in the ERCOT region | By 1 December each year: wind breaks where wind causes outages, insulation and enclosures for all cold weather critical components, maintenance of freeze protection equipment, and monitoring of critical components including the circuits that provide freeze protection. |
| 16 Texas Administrative Code §3.66, Weather Emergency Preparedness Standards (Railroad Commission of Texas) | Critical gas supply chain and gas pipeline facilities in Texas | Weather emergency preparation measures at the facility. The Commission’s 2026 guidance document lists impulse lines, usually stainless-steel tubing, among the items that freeze, and advises operators to insulate and heat-trace vulnerable instrumentation lines. |
EOP-012-3 and §25.55 do not mention sensing lines, transmitters or heat tracing by name. Which components are critical is decided by the owner for each unit.
Lines that are usually at risk
These are typical examples from general plant practice. Your own list comes from your unit’s cold weather critical component review.
- Drum level and feedwater flow transmitters: water-filled differential-pressure legs that must stay liquid and at the same condition on both sides.
- Steam pressure and flow transmitters with condensate-filled legs.
- Fuel gas pressure and flow measurement, where moisture or hydrates can block a small tube.
- Cooling water, condensate and service water pressure switches and transmitters that sit outdoors.
- Instrument air lines, where moisture collects and freezes at low points.
- Analyser and emissions (CEMS) sample lines, which must also stay above the sample dew point.
Why wind and run time matter in the design
A sensing line is small, so it has little heat stored in it and a large surface for its volume. In still air a modest heater keeps it above freezing. In wind, the heat loss from an exposed or poorly sealed line rises sharply, and a line that survived a calm night can freeze in a few hours.
That is why EOP-012-3 states a wind speed and a duration for new units: the unit’s Extreme Cold Weather Temperature, a sustained 20 mph (32 km/h) wind, and at least 12 continuous hours. When you ask for a traced line, give the supplier the same three figures so the heat-loss calculation matches the condition you have to document.
Insulation that is wet, crushed or open at the ends loses much of its value. A continuous outer jacket and sealed ends keep rain and wash-down water out of the insulation, which is where field-wrapped lines often fail.
Field-traced sensing lines
- Tube, heating cable, insulation and weather barrier are installed separately on site.
- Quality depends on each joint in the insulation and cladding staying dry.
- Suits short runs and lines that must follow existing tubing.
- Inspection means checking the cable, the insulation and the cladding along the run.
Factory-made tubing bundle
- Tube, tracer, insulation and extruded jacket arrive as one continuous length.
- The jacket is continuous, so water enters only at the ends, which are sealed during installation.
- Suits new lines and replacement of runs that have failed.
- The construction is the same along the whole length, so one heat-loss calculation covers the run.
Bundle options for freeze protection
Techwin builds each bundle to the customer’s specification. These are the constructions used for freeze protection.
| Construction | How it protects the line | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Electric traced bundle with self-regulating cable | The cable raises its output as the tube gets colder and lowers it as the tube warms. The low-temperature range maintains about 40 °C (104 °F). | Most transmitter and sensing lines where power is available |
| Steam traced bundle, light tracing | A tracer tube carries plant steam and is separated from the process tube, so the line is kept from freezing without overheating. | Plants with steam at the line and a route for condensate |
| Pre-insulated tubing (no tracer) | Insulation and jacket slow the heat loss. There is no heat source. | Lines that flow, or short exposures. It does not prevent freezing in a line that stands still through a long cold period. |
The standard FR-PVC jacket is rated −40 °C to 105 °C (−40 °F to 221 °F). Heating cables in Techwin bundles carry IECEx, ATEX and IEC certification issued to the cable manufacturer. If your site requires a North American listing for the heating cable, state it in the enquiry so we can confirm whether we can meet it before you order.
What to send for a quotation
- The unit’s Extreme Cold Weather Temperature, or the lowest ambient you design for
- Design wind speed and how long the line must hold (for example 20 mph for 12 hours)
- What is in the line: water, steam condensate, gas or sample, and the temperature to hold
- Tube material, size, wall thickness and number of tubes
- Length of each run
- Supply voltage, or steam pressure, at the line
- Area classification and the approval or listing your site requires for electrical equipment
- Jacket environment: sunlight, chemicals, wash-down
Keeping the protection working
The rules ask for records as well as hardware. These steps are general practice for traced lines.
- List each traced line against the critical component it protects.
- Before each winter, check that every heating circuit is energised and drawing current, and that steam tracers are hot and their traps are working.
- Look for damaged jacket, open end seals and wet insulation, and repair them before the cold season.
- Keep the supplier’s design data and installation records with the unit’s cold weather preparedness plan.
Sources
- NERC Reliability Standard EOP-012-3 (nerc.com, PDF)
- FERC, NERC and Regional Entity Joint Staff Report on the February 2021 cold weather outages, staff presentation (nerc.com, PDF)
- 16 Tex. Admin. Code §25.55, Weather Emergency Preparedness (text at Cornell LII)
- Railroad Commission of Texas, Weatherization Practices Guidance Document 2026 (rrc.texas.gov, PDF)
Frequently asked questions
Does NERC EOP-012 require heat tracing on sensing lines?
Not by name. EOP-012-3 requires Generator Owners to identify their Generator Cold Weather Critical Components and to implement, document, inspect and maintain freeze protection measures on them. The owner decides which components are critical and how to protect them. Sensing lines are often on that list because the 2021 investigation found frozen transmitters and sensing lines behind a large share of freezing outages.
What wind speed should freeze protection be designed for?
For generating units that enter commercial operation on or after 1 October 2027, EOP-012-3 states the unit’s Extreme Cold Weather Temperature with a sustained 20 mph (32 km/h) wind for at least 12 continuous hours. Earlier units must have freeze protection for their Extreme Cold Weather Temperature or a corrective action plan. Use the figures from your own unit’s review when you specify a traced line.
Why do instrument sensing lines freeze before larger pipes?
They are small, often filled with water, and usually do not flow. A small tube stores little heat and loses it quickly, especially in wind or when its insulation is wet. A frozen line gives the transmitter a false reading, which can trip the unit.
Is pre-insulated tubing enough for freeze protection?
Only where the line flows or the cold period is short. Insulation slows heat loss but adds no heat, so a line that stands still through a long freeze will reach ambient temperature. Those lines need electric or steam tracing under the insulation.
Preparing sensing lines for next winter?
Send the design temperature, wind speed, line contents, tube sizes and run lengths. Our engineers will propose a bundle construction for your condition and price it.
Request a quote